2025 MLB Hall of Fame Early Voting Results: Players Gaining Support and Climbing Toward 75%

Bobby Abreu (6th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 24.1%
• Abreu, known for his power-speed combination, had a solid career, though his Hall of Fame candidacy has not gained significant traction. He was a consistent contributor across his 18-season career but has not garnered the same widespread attention as other candidates. This is his 6th appearance on the ballot.

Carlos Beltrán (3rd Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 81.1%
• Beltrán is edging close to induction. With his exceptional career as a switch hitter, great defensive play, and leadership in the postseason, he’s almost certain to be inducted, needing only a small increase to cross the 75% threshold. This is his 3rd appearance on the ballot.

Mark Buehrle (5th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 12.3%
• A reliable and durable pitcher, Buehrle earned 5 Gold Gloves and threw a perfect game in 2009. His consistency over his 16-season career may eventually lead to induction, but it will take time to convince voters. This is his 5th appearance on the ballot.

Carlos González (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• González, known for his time with the Colorado Rockies, had flashes of brilliance, particularly as a hitter. However, his career was marked by inconsistency, and it remains unlikely that he’ll gain significant support for the Hall of Fame. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Curtis Granderson (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Granderson was known for his leadership and his ability to hit for power and steal bases. However, his overall career numbers may not be strong enough to push him to the 75% threshold. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Félix Hernández (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 24.1%
• A former Cy Young Award winner, Hernández was one of the most dominant pitchers of his era. However, his lack of postseason success and a decline in performance as he aged may hurt his chances. Despite his elite seasons, his case for the Hall remains in question. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Torii Hunter (5th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 2.4%
• Hunter, a 9-time Gold Glove winner and 5-time All-Star, had a great career as a defensive standout and strong leader in the clubhouse. His case for the Hall of Fame will be a tough sell, especially as his offensive numbers may not stand up to other players with similar career length. This is his 5th appearance on the ballot.

Adam Jones (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Jones was a key contributor for the Baltimore Orioles, both offensively and defensively. However, while he was a consistent All-Star, he lacks the standout accomplishments or career milestones that would make him a strong candidate for induction. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Andruw Jones (8th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 72.6%
• Andruw Jones is a near-lock for induction based on his defensive prowess and power numbers. A 10-time Gold Glove winner and 400+ home runs hitter, his legacy as one of the greatest center fielders in history is undeniable. He is very close to reaching the necessary 75% for Hall of Fame induction. This is his 8th appearance on the ballot.

Ian Kinsler (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 3.3%
• Kinsler was a highly productive second baseman with power and speed, earning multiple Gold Gloves and All-Star selections. However, his numbers don’t match up with other Hall of Fame second basemen, and his support will need to grow considerably for him to stay on the ballot. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Russell Martin (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 3.3%
• Martin had a strong career as a catcher known for his defense, leadership, and on-base skills. However, he lacks the offensive dominance or other standout achievements that would help him gain the necessary support to be elected to the Hall. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Brian McCann (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 3.3%
• McCann was a solid power-hitting catcher and a 7-time All-Star, but his career may not have the longevity or high enough peaks to make him a Hall of Fame-caliber player. Like Martin, his case may not gather the necessary support for induction. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Dustin Pedroia (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 15.1%
• Pedroia, a 2008 MVP and 4-time Gold Glove winner, had a distinguished career as one of the best second basemen in his era. However, injuries curtailed his career, and it remains uncertain whether his shortened career will be enough to earn him a spot in Cooperstown. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Andy Pettitte (7th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 31.6%
• Pettitte, a key contributor to the Yankees’ dynasty, has five World Series rings and over 250 career wins. His postseason success and longevity give him a strong case for induction, but his relatively modest career statistics will require a sustained push from voters. This is his 7th appearance on the ballot.

Hanley Ramírez (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Ramírez was one of the most dynamic shortstops during his prime, earning a batting title and multiple All-Star appearances. However, his career was marked by inconsistency and injuries, and he doesn’t have the sustained excellence necessary to gain significant Hall of Fame support. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Manny Ramírez (9th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 35.8%
• One of the greatest hitters of his generation, Manny Ramírez was a feared slugger with a career full of accolades, including 12 All-Star appearances and two World Series titles. Despite his success, his history of PED suspensions continues to hurt his chances of induction, though he remains a formidable candidate. This is his 9th appearance on the ballot.

Fernando Rodney (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Rodney was a reliable closer, best known for his time with the Tampa Bay Rays. However, his overall career numbers, particularly his lack of dominance compared to other Hall of Fame relievers, make it unlikely that he’ll gain enough support to remain on the ballot. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Álex Rodríguez (4th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 40.1%
• Rodríguez is one of the most accomplished players in baseball history, with over 700 home runs and 3,000 hits. However, his legacy is tainted by multiple suspensions for PED use, and while he may eventually get in, his path to induction is complicated by these controversies. This is his 4th appearance on the ballot.

Francisco Rodríguez (3rd Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 8.0%
• Rodríguez, one of the best closers of all time with a career-record 62-save season, faces an uphill battle to gain Hall of Fame support. While he had a dominant career, closers are often scrutinized more heavily, and his chances depend on continued support. This is his 3rd appearance on the ballot.

Jimmy Rollins (4th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 20.3%
• Rollins was a key player for the Phillies, known for his defense, speed, and leadership. His 2007 MVP award and World Series title add to his resume, but his overall offensive production may not be enough to push him to 75%. This is his 4th appearance on the ballot.

CC Sabathia (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 92.5%
• Sabathia, a workhorse left-hander with over 250 wins and a Cy Young Award, is almost certain to be inducted. His longevity and success on the mound make him one of the top pitchers of his generation, and he will likely cross the 75% threshold in the near future. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Ichiro Suzuki (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 100.0%
• Ichiro is a guaranteed first-ballot Hall of Famer, with over 4,000 hits between MLB and Japan. His combination of contact hitting, fielding, and durability makes him one of the most iconic players in baseball history, and he will easily pass the 75% threshold. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Troy Tulowitzki (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Tulowitzki was an elite shortstop for several years, known for his defense and power. However, injuries derailed his career, and his overall numbers don’t measure up to typical Hall of Fame standards. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.

Chase Utley (2nd Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 51.9%
• Utley, a dynamic second baseman known for his power, defense, and leadership, is gaining significant support. His Hall of Fame case will likely depend on continued backing as more voters recognize his impact on the game. This is his 2nd appearance on the ballot.

Omar Vizquel (8th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 12.7%
• Vizquel, regarded as one of the best defensive shortstops in baseball history, has not gained significant support for induction. His offensive numbers are often seen as lacking, and this has limited his Hall of Fame candidacy. This is his 8th appearance on the ballot.

Billy Wagner (10th Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 85.4%
• Wagner, one of the most dominant closers in MLB history, is very close to induction. His strikeout numbers and consistency make him a worthy candidate, and he will likely gain the necessary support in the near future. This is his 10th appearance on the ballot.

David Wright (2nd Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 10.8%
• Wright, known for his leadership and success with the Mets, had a strong career but was plagued by injuries that shortened his prime. His case for the Hall of Fame will require strong continued support, as his peak years may not be enough for induction. This is his 2nd appearance on the ballot.

Ben Zobrist (1st Appearance)

• Current Percentage: 0.0%
• Zobrist, celebrated for his versatility and pivotal role in the Cubs’ 2016 World Series title, has a unique case. However, his lack of individual accolades and relatively modest career numbers make him a longshot for induction. This is his 1st appearance on the ballot.