Mets Eyeing Reunion with Max Scherzer - Here’s What It Means!

Reports suggest that the New York Mets are actively showing interest in a reunion with none other than Max Scherzer, the grizzled veteran starting pitcher who's guaranteed a spot in Cooperstown. The news has fans split—some are calling for an encore of Mad Max in Queens, while others are hesitant to revisit a past that didn’t quite end on a high note.

So, what’s going on here, and why are the Mets interested in bringing back the soon-to-be 40-year-old pitcher? Let’s break it all down from every angle—performance, sentimentality, and strategy.

Where the Rumors Began

The Scherzer speculation initially surfaced when the multi-time Cy Young winner threw for scouts at the Sports Performance Pro Day recently. According to reports from reputable sources, including SNY and Sports Illustrated-affiliated Pat Ragazzo, multiple teams were in attendance, ranging from the Yankees and Dodgers to the Blue Jays and Braves. But one surprising suitor? The Mets.

The idea of bringing back Scherzer comes after two polarizing seasons in Queens, where he displayed flashes of brilliance but faltered in critical playoff moments. Nevertheless, the Mets reportedly see value in adding Mad Max back into their pitching ranks—albeit on a one-year deal. The logic? Low risk, high upside with an added dash of veteran leadership.

Why Scherzer May Not Make Sense

Let’s address the elephant in the room first—why do some Mets fans grimace at the idea of a second stint for Scherzer?

• His declining velocity—With his fastball clocking in at an average of 92 to 93 mph in 2024, the signs of regression are undeniable. Even with his elite pedigree, Scherzer’s days as a dominant ace appear to be behind him.
• Health concerns—Scherzer only logged around 50 innings last season, and his injury history is becoming harder to ignore. Pitching deep into October feels like a long shot unless he stays remarkably fit.
• Playoff baggage—The memories of his poor outings in the 2022 Wild Card round are still fresh. For fans who attended that infamous series against the Padres, the sting remains palpable.

Simply put, Scherzer isn’t getting any younger, and his last impression in a Mets uniform wasn’t exactly inspiring. However, not everything about this potential reunion tilts negative.

The Case for Bringing Max Back

For every detractor, there’s a fan who’s excited at the idea of Mad Max donning orange and blue again. And honestly, there are some legitimate reasons to support this move.

• Elite Chase and Whiff Rates: Despite a tough 2024, Scherzer ranked in the 100th percentile in chase rates and was well above league average in whiff percentage. Even with reduced velocity, he’s proven capable of making hitters miss.
• Short-Term Deal: The Mets are reportedly interested in Scherzer on a one-year, low-commitment contract. If it doesn’t work out, the financial and on-field consequences are minimal.
• Veteran Leadership: Scherzer’s clubhouse presence is reportedly a significant boost for young talent. He demands professionalism and brings a competitive edge that rubs off on others.
• Established Relationships: With Juan Soto and Francisco Lindor anchoring the Mets’ infield, Scherzer would reunite with former teammates and close friends, creating natural chemistry for the clubhouse.

Perhaps the realistic view here is that Scherzer isn’t returning to be the ace of a staff—but rather as a serviceable four or five starter in a rotation that includes Kodai Senga and a collection of promising arms. At his best, he might surprise with flashes of his prime. At his worst, the Mets cut bait and move on.

Is This Move Realistic?

All signs suggest Scherzer’s market is developing quickly, with plenty of interested suitors, including potential division rivals like the Braves. The Mets will need to act fast if they’re serious about a reunion. And there’s certainly logic behind the move. When presented alongside other available options like Griffin Canning or Paul Blackburn, Scherzer arguably offers the highest upside.

What will ultimately sway the Mets might not just be Scherzer’s arm, but his willingness to accept a flexible role. Would he pitch fewer innings in a six-man rotation? Would he accept a bullpen move if required? These questions will play a major role in determining whether Scherzer becomes a Met once more.

Fans Are Torn

Perhaps the most intriguing aspect of this potential reunion is how divided the fanbase is. Many simply can’t let go of his 2022 playoff performance and 2023 struggles, while others see it as a low-stakes proposition with considerable upside. Ultimately, the decision will come down to whether David Stearns and Steve Cohen believe Scherzer still has enough left in the tank to justify another shot.

For now, the only certainty is that the Mets’ rotation remains a work in progress, and the rumor mill isn’t slowing down anytime soon.

What do you think? Should the Mets give Mad Max another chance, or is it time to move forward? Share your thoughts below!